Felicia D.
5/29/2023
We stopped at the sweet aunt on my birthday to get some cupcakes, and they did not disappoint! The shop has limited hours, but the "vault" is like a vending machine for different treats of theirs...
Icing on the Lake
Permanently closed
(46)
Photos
940 W Erie Plz
Erie, PA 16505
Specialties
Icing on the Lake creates homemade treats and desserts including cupcakes, cookies, pies, cakes, cake pops, french macaroons and just about anything sweet! We also offer custom occasion cakes. Anything you can dream we will bake and decorate!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.546 reviews
Tanha K.
10/21/2024
I was so bummed when the actual storefront closed, but I will say the sweet vault which is filled with their treats is a decent substitute and a unique experience in Erie. The prices are a bit...
Marcelle R.
6/28/2025
Was my favorite bakery in Erie until they closed. Loved their cream puffs. They now have vending machine you can get some goodies.
Rachel A.
7/4/2022
The BEST bakery in Erie (you heard it here)!! Incredible selection of baked goods that can be bought in store or ordered! The cupcakes are the best ones I've ever had and bakers are incredibly...
Aly W.
7/17/2019
I went first thing in the morning before we drove over to Niagara. These ladies are SO NICE. I cannot stress enough how awesome it is to walk into bright smiling faces. We were all swooning of a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.