Lisa S.
9/14/2025
I finally understand why everyone speaks so highly of Gaeta's. I'd heard of this famous tomato pie from an Eagles fan being interviewed on Tik Tok. Since then, I've wanted to try it for myself....
Gaeta's Italian Bakery
$
Open
(70)
Photos
7616 Castor Ave
Philadelphia, PA 19152
Gaeta's Italian Bakery in Philadelphia, PA is a cash-only establishment offering a delectable selection of Italian baked goods. Their menu features original square tomato pies available in various sizes, as well as a range of stuffed breads like Stromboli with options such as pepperoni & cheese, steak & cheese, and buffalo chicken & cheese.
Patrons can also indulge in traditional cheese pizzas, sandwiches like the signature roast pork on fresh bread, and an assortment of toppings including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and roasted garlic. With a reputation for friendly service and exceptional food, Gaeta's is a go-to spot for those seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Reviewers rave about the quality of the tomato pies, highlighting the perfect balance of flavors and the crispy, thin crust. Additionally, the welcoming atmosphere and accommodating staff make Gaeta's a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike, ensuring a delightful culinary experience with every visit.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.570 reviews
Andrew B.
5/26/2025
My wife and I were visiting Philly and on Memorial Day were searching for tomato pie. This place came highly recommended. SPECTACULAR tomato pie. As someone who grew up in NYC eating at old...
Ed S.
9/1/2025
Wow .. I'm impressed. I'm a huge tomato pie fan and I've tried those from several different well-known places And this is absolutely fabulous! The tomato pies I've had in the past, while highly...
Dominicke S.
5/14/2025
This place was my wife's favorite as a child, it is now a household favorite. Food and service are always top notch. I've called in ahead and ordered when I got there. The staff have a way of...
G M.
6/21/2024
No real Italian bakery would use CANNED tomatoes in the sauce. Gaeta's does, so they are not the real thing. Service is extremely slow, prices are high, and service is polite. The store is tiny...
See a problem?
