Scarlett D.
6/21/2025
The items are delish, pizza, subs, just about everything on the menu. The only disappointment would be the person taking my order, I was ordering a pizza, told them what I wanted but wanted...
Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs
$
Closed
(14)
Photos
1506 Old Butler Rd
New Castle, PA 16101
There’s nothing better than fresh-out-of-the oven food delivered straight to your door. For the best Italian cuisine in New Castle, PA, choose Four Star Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs. From their unbeatable specialty pizzas to their homemade, you’ll soon make this restaurant your go-to spot for lunch and dinner. Take a break from cooking for the family tonight and visit Four Star Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs. Visit their website to browse their menu, and call (724) 656-9222 to place a takeout or delivery order. Be sure to ask about their daily specials!
Also at this address
Reviews
2.514 reviews
Rick L.
2/22/2025
First time order from four star. Got a 12" deluxe delivered, arrived quick, and was still hot. Sauce is tangy, crust isn't oily, well cooked. I'm very happy with it. I'll be ordering again.
Gage C.
10/15/2022
Worst customer service I've ever experienced, I've been a patron of this business for awhile and I will never eat here again they are extremely rude and unprofessional I highly recommend you spend...
Susan G.
8/14/2020
I ordered a steak hoagie with mushrooms and they sent me an Italian sub with no mushrooms I called back and told her they sent the wrong sub that I ordered a steak hoagie and she said oh did it...
Greg V.
12/23/2020
Pizza is decent enough to eat but the staff is kind of lazy with the cooking. Got wings the last two times and they didn't seem like they were fully cooked and didn't really have any sauce on...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.