Gracie D.
6/24/2025
Being that I am from the general area this shop is located in, I cannot believe I have both never visited nor heard of it until recently! I discovered this place from a quick Google search, and am...
Country Custard Cottage
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
1503 Mars Hill Rd
Sutersville, PA 15083
Located in the charming town of Sutersville, PA, Country Custard Cottage is a delightful ice cream shop that beckons locals and travelers alike with its irresistible frozen treats. Nestled in a cozy corner, this inviting spot offers a wide array of flavors that cater to every palate, from classic vanilla to exotic mango swirl. The quaint ambiance and friendly staff make it the perfect place to satisfy your sweet cravings on a sunny afternoon.
Step into Country Custard Cottage and be greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly churned ice cream, made with top-quality ingredients that promise a creamy, indulgent experience with every scoop. Whether you're a fan of traditional sundaes or adventurous enough to try their signature flavors, this hidden gem is a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of nostalgia served in a cone. Take a leisurely stroll through Sutersville and treat yourself to a scoop of happiness at Country Custard Cottage—you won't be disappointed.
Generated using this place's available information
Reviews
4.521 reviews
Seth L.
7/13/2025
Great service. Horrible ice cream... the flavors i had tasted like febrerze... if i go back I'll get vanilla but the flavors taste like straight up chemicals... really good pies and pepperoni...
Ryan F.
8/11/2022
This place is the best ice cream joint in Westmoreland County, and that beats out Kerbers who has great hard ice cream. Check my review for that place if you prefer hard ice cream. The difference...
K W.
9/2/2024
Adorable shop with delicious custard. The workers are always smiling and ready to take your order. Don't see what you crave on the menu? Just ask, and they will make your special order.
Lindsy S.
12/27/2024
Hands down the best place for cold dessert outside of Pittsburgh! I have not indulged in their pastries yet. They look as tasty as their custard. Definitely worth the drive from the city.
See a problem?
