Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery

$
Closed
yelp logo

(14)

Photos

117 E State St
Pleasantville, PA 16341

Nestled in the heart of Pleasantville, PA, Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery is a quintessential American restaurant that captures the essence of comfort dining with a touch of nostalgia. The charming establishment exudes a welcoming ambiance, inviting patrons to savor classic American fare in a cozy setting reminiscent of a bygone era. From the moment guests step inside, they are greeted by the warm aromas of hearty dishes and the friendly chatter of fellow diners, creating a sense of community and camaraderie.

With its menu featuring a delectable array of traditional American favorites, Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery promises a culinary experience that is both familiar and satisfying. Whether craving a juicy burger with all the fixings, a crispy fried chicken platter, or a decadent slice of homemade pie, diners can indulge in timeless comfort foods prepared with care and attention to detail. The restaurant's dedication to quality ingredients and flavorful recipes ensures that every bite is a delicious trip down memory lane, making Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery a beloved dining destination for locals and visitors alike.

Generated using this place's available information

Reviews

yelp logo
4.014 reviews
Photo of Olivia P.
Olivia P.
4/26/2015

Coal oil Johnny's is a cute little restaurant in the middle of nowhere close to the camp grounds. The menu has a great selection of American style food. There are also cute souvineers in the shop...

Photo of Tashina R.
Tashina R.
10/31/2025

Service was fast. Atmosphere is cozy. Food is good and cheap. If we're in the area we will definitely stop again.

Photo of Lana C.
Lana C.
10/10/2021

Decent menu selection. Lots of seating. The food tasted decent and is definitely one of the better places to eat at around the area. But I'm giving 2/5 stars because of cleanliness. Our silverware...

Photo of Andrew O.
Andrew O.
10/6/2023

Always Ate here when I was younger great food and service great people a lot of seats

Photo of Felicia W.
Felicia W.
7/1/2022

Good menu, good atmosphere, good food, quick and polite waitresses and great pie! Also purchased one of the photos from the wall as a gift and it was loved! Cute little place.

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesPennsylvaniaPleasantvilleCoal Oil Johnny's Eatery

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.