Lawrence T.
11/10/2021
Tasty ice cream. Friendly staff. Affordable home made ice cream. Do you need more than that? Very tasty ice cream. So many flavors to like! Peanut butter is a family favorite. Basic...
Carman's Ice Cream
$
Closed
(25)
Photos
1109 Hanover Rd
York, PA 17408
Carman's Ice Cream, nestled in Loganville, PA, offers a delightful retreat for ice cream aficionados and families alike. What initially began as a backyard indulgence in 1953 on Ervin Carman's porch has blossomed into a cherished destination for those seeking premium quality ice cream. The Carman family's dedication to crafting old-fashioned ice cream using top-notch ingredients and their treasured recipe has garnered a loyal following.
Located conveniently off PA Rt. 45, Carman's Homemade Ice Cream beckons visitors with its nostalgic charm and commitment to traditional ice cream-making methods. Open seven days a week, this quaint establishment welcomes guests to savor a scoop of their renowned flavors from 9:00 AM to 8:30 PM, offering a sweet conclusion to a day of exploration. Situated between Loganville and Jacobus, PA, just 5 miles north of Glen Rock, Carman's embodies the essence of a bygone era, inviting patrons to indulge in a taste of the past.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
4.025 reviews
Dane S.
4/1/2025
I know there is a lot of complaints on how the taste has changed. Maybe it's a raw material issue or maybe they just changed things up, who knows. I still find it better than going to one of the...
Andrew S.
4/11/2025
Definitely not the Carmens I remember.I'm not saying that it's not good. It's just not what I remember. service today was excellent. Selection was average.flavor was good. ...not my favorite ....
Al L.
5/9/2025
Sorry to the locals that like this just because it's local, but Carman's is inferior to the widely distributed Turkey Hill and Green's. So obviously it can't come close to competing with the...
Melissa P.
11/4/2022
I grew up eating Carmen's ice cream. My favorite vanilla and chocolate. But the half gallons I purchased about 2 weeks ago were not the same as usual. Especially the vanilla. Something is off with...
See a problem?
