Tim H.
7/1/2025
The pizzas are so big you only need one maybe two slices and they're so tasty. You will finish every bite. The service was fast and friendly and I've been back many of times. The ambience,...
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria
$
Closed
(54)
Photos
3312 S Elm Pl
Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is an authentic family-owned pizzeria in Broken Arrow, OK, offering hot and fresh New York-style pizza by the slice or whole pie, along with a variety of delicious pasta dishes and mouthwatering desserts.
With a commitment to quality and made-to-order freshness, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria ensures that customers always get the best pizza and pasta experience, while also expressing their support and gratitude to veterans and law enforcement.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.554 reviews
Courtney E.
8/25/2024
My husband and I visited on a Saturday afternoon around 2:30pm. There was one table that was clean - three or four tables were occupied and the rest had not been cleaned off yet. They appeared to...
Gilberto S.
8/19/2025
I am an old Brooklyn boy. Jimmy's is the closest you will find in this area to Authentic New York Style pizza. Jimmy makes his own tomato sauce just like in Brooklyn. The pastas are awesome and...
Stanley W.
11/16/2024
As a New Yorker, I'm happy to have found Jimmy's with their authentic NY pizza. Great dough, crust, and flavor. We had the Brooklyn pie today and all the ingredients tasted so fresh. With Sinatra...
Lynzi H.
1/6/2024
Jimmys is one of our FAVORITE pizza places and we were so excited to see it on here for delivery! Pizza is excellent as always has a nice flop to it, full of flavor and the crust is done...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.