Goodfella's Pizzeria

$
Open
yelp logo

(23)

Call
Website

Photos

450677 E 85 Hwy
Afton, OK 74331
+1 (918) 782-2000
http://www.mygoodfellaspizza.com

Goodfella's Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment based in Afton, Oklahoma, dedicated to crafting a unique style of pizza. Since opening its first location in Vinita in 2005, the company has expanded to include additional locations in Cleora, Grove, and Miami, Oklahoma.

The pizzeria prides itself on delivering not only delicious pizza but also the friendliest service in the region. With a commitment to quality and community, Goodfella's Pizzeria continues to delight customers throughout northeastern Oklahoma.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.523 reviews
Photo of Edgar S.
Edgar S.
11/18/2017

I consider myself a pizza snob. I have pretty high standards for pizza and this place did not let me down. The crust was nice and soft and the dough does not sit heavy. Make sure whatever you...

Read more on Yelp
Montgomery Gator ..
6/26/2025

Drove up and saw a worker picking calluses off her feet don't recommend this place at all.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Sarah F.
Sarah F.
5/25/2022

We stopped in with some hungry teenage boys after getting our rv set up. This place is pretty small with just a few tables. We ordered a supreme pizza, a large cheese, and a large pepperoni. This...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Anna F.
Anna F.
12/15/2021

Such a delicious meal from here while staying nearby at Grand Lake! There are lots of pizza spots to choose from around the area, but this is clearly the best. The chicken bacon ranch sub was...

Read more on Yelp
David C.
1/1/2023

Pizza is da bomb. I love this place. Staff is super friendly. There are several around Grand Lake. This one is in Cleora

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Eating places

Gambino's Pizza

9
•
$
"We were told this place had great pizza so we decided to try it. The menu is impressive and there's..."
photo of Lisa H
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Pizza restaurants

Simple Simon's Pizza

$$
Simple Simon's Pizza in Afton, OK offers dine-in, carryout, and curbside services for customers seeking quality pizza made with fresh ingredients. With over 200 stores conveniently located nationwide, Simple Simon's Pizza prides itself on fast service and great prices, making it a go-to choice for delicious and affordable pizza. Whether you're looking to enjoy a meal in-store or take it to go, Simple Simon's Pizza provides a menu filled with a variety of options to satisfy your pizza cravings. For those interested in joining the Simple Simon's Pizza family, franchise and licensing opportunities are available for individuals looking to bring the brand to new communities. Generated from the website
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Simple Simon's Pizza

$
Simple Simon's Pizza in Afton, OK offers dine-in, carryout, and curbside services for customers looking to enjoy their delicious pizzas made with quality ingredients at great prices. With over 200 stores conveniently located across the country, Simple Simon's Pizza is known for its fast service and commitment to providing the best pizza experience. Customers can start their order online or by calling their local store to find out more about the menu options available. For those interested in joining the Simple Simon's Pizza family, franchise and licensing opportunities are also offered for individuals looking to bring the brand to new locations. Generated from the website
United States›Oklahoma›Afton›Goodfella's Pizzeria

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.