El Maguey Mexican Restaurant

This was our first, but definitely not our last, visit. The restaurant is tucked inside a shopping mall just off Hwy. 66 as you drive into Claremore from Tulsa. First impressions: there's a lot...

My ribeye came out just how I asked, with a beautiful crust and tender inside. I liked that it had a natural beefy flavor without needing a ton of seasoning. The portion size was generous and left...

The steak was tender and full of flavor, definitely the highlight of my meal. I got the house special and it came with grilled mushrooms and onions. Everything tasted freshly made and well...

I came in here about 7:45pm on May 30, 2025. I ordered chips n salsa and a medium queso to go. I sit to wait. The guy who took my order brings me the check. Now I can do math $6.99 (chips n salsa)...

The tacos had such a great balance of flavor and spice. The meat was tender and the toppings added great texture. Super casual spot with quick service. I could easily eat three more without even...