Grace J.
11/7/2021
literally the best pizza in stillwater! you can tell these people really care about their customers AND their pizza. personally, i think this place is better than the hideaway. highly recommend...
Cindy's Pizza
Closed
(8)
Photos
3507 S Husband St
Stillwater, OK 74074
Cindy's Pizza LLC is a renowned pizzeria in Stillwater, OK, known for serving the best NY-style brick oven pizza in town. Their dough, pizza sauce, and dipping sauces are made fresh daily using top-quality ingredients, and cooked to perfection in a brick oven.
Locals rave about Cindy's Pizza, claiming it to be the finest pizza in the area. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also offer a variety of fresh desserts and other items, all available for take and bake at the Homeland store on Main St.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.58 reviews
Jackie M.
7/29/2023
Bought one of Cindy's frozen pizzas at the Oasis on the west side of town. It was very good. Easy to put it in the oven for a quick meal. Definitely better than frozen options at the grocery store.
Owen E.
5/26/2024
The best Pizza in Stillwater hands down. Cindy is a very sweet woman and cares about her customers and the quality of the pizza!! I will definitely be ordering again.
Peyton K.
2/16/2024
Skip Hideaway and get you a pizza from Cindy's. Best part about Cindy's, outside of the pizza, is the box has a target on the back. Awesome.
Pedro J.
11/19/2022
They don't have burnt crusts like the Hideaway. I will try them again to get some of their signature garlic bread. They don't seem bothered to have customers come into their business like so many...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.