Jered M.
12/8/2020
Grew up in Winesburg and visited this store almost multiple times a day while living with my grand parents. My grandparents Andy and Barb Wengerd have both passed since then. We used to kick the...
Whitmer’s Pizza & General Store
$$
Closed
(10)
Photos
2105 Main St
New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Whitmer’s Pizza & General Store in New Philadelphia, OH, is a renowned establishment with a rich historical background. The old general store offers visitors a unique experience with its nostalgic ambiance and carefully selected antique displays. Patrons can enjoy excellent food while immersing themselves in the charm of a bygone era.
Not just a place to dine, Whitmer’s is a fully functional general store catering to both locals and out-of-town guests. For those looking to host special events, the establishment also offers private event services, ensuring a memorable experience for all attendees. Whether it's a pizza party or a large gathering, Whitmer’s is dedicated to accommodating diverse needs and requests.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
2.510 reviews
Michelle C.
11/21/2023
I order to go from this place due to the reviews online. First the price is way too high! We basically paid $50 for one large cheese and one large meat lovers. Second- the pizza dough was too...
Caroline H.
3/23/2024
My boyfriend and I stopped in to see the general store while visiting Amish country, and loved the smell of the pizzas being made in the back of the store so decided to give a try. What a mistake...
Rhonda M.
9/6/2020
Stopped in to get ice cream & found the general store had so much more. My hubby got a strawberry sundae while I ordered a peanut butter cup "blizzard" with chocolate ice cream. After eating our...
Sherri B.
5/26/2023
The outside of the this store/pizzeria is cute and charming, and the inside still has features of a general store of years past. However, there are issues with customer service and the pathetic...
See a problem?
