In Moderation ..
9/3/2025
There's a lot to love about this pizza -- the flavors are spot on, the sauce has the right balance of tang and sweetness, and the toppings are always fresh and generous. When it's done right, it's...
Tiberio's Pizza
Closed
(9)
Photos
416 N Columbus St
Lancaster, OH 43130
Tiberio's Pizza in Lancaster, OH, has been a beloved local establishment since 1990, serving up delicious pizzas, Stromboli, and homemade pasta fresh every day. Situated at 416 N Columbus St, the restaurant offers a welcoming dining room with ample and cozy seating for a comfortable experience.
Not only does Tiberio's provide an inviting space for dine-in guests, but they also cater to those looking for convenience with their carry-out and delivery options. The menu boasts a variety of options, from mouth-watering pizzas to flavorful subs, pastas, salads, and delectable desserts, ensuring something for every palate.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
2.09 reviews
Jacob S.
8/17/2025
Really wish I could give more stars. Small seating area inside, decent size bar. Service was slow, it appeared to be two folks, one behind the bar and another roaming. I have had the food before,...
Hank C.
9/26/2025
2nd time trying the place while I'm in Lancaster for work. Terrible service both times. You're ignored if you aren't a local regular customer. This visit took the cake. Literally walked in between...
Michael T.
5/28/2025
SLOW. Would be different if the place was busy but we tried to get lunch and there was maybe 6 other people besides our group of four in the entire place. Ordered drinks, ordered food then just...
Bob S.
8/9/2025
Sat for over an hour before we received our orders. Their salad was greens, 1/2 of a slice of tomato and 2 pieces of salami, that tasted "odd"None of the other items that were listed on the menu...
See a problem?
