The Pizzeria

Closed

(4)

Call

Website

Photos

206 E Main St

Pandora, OH 45877

+1 (419) 384-7222

http://www.thepizzeria.org

The Pizzeria, a family-owned establishment operated by brothers Brent and Curt Shafer, has been a staple in Putnam County since 1972. With a commitment to serving the finest pizza, the restaurant prides itself on using the freshest quality toppings and an unchanging pizza sauce recipe that has delighted customers for over five decades.

Employing traditional deck ovens instead of quicker conveyor ovens, The Pizzeria believes in providing a superior pizza experience. Brent and Curt are actively involved in the kitchen, reflecting their hands-on approach to preserving the company's dedication to quality and community engagement.

Generated from the website

Reviews

2.54 reviews

Mike W.

5/26/2017

This was our first time to Pandora Ohio. This restaurant was right around the corner. We ordered pizza, baked subs, mozzarella sticks, and the small calzones. Oh, and a personal pasta. First,...

Read more on Yelp

Makenna M.

2/17/2024

We ordered a simple gluten free pepperoni pizza. Instead of pepperoni we got mushrooms, olive, and onions. This is the second time that this has happened in the last 2 orders.

Read more on Yelp

Lara C.

9/4/2022

We are not from around the area, so we were just taking a chance in the area. The service was odd. We were handed menus and told that the prices aren't right, but never told what the correct...

Read more on Yelp

Lauren G.

8/21/2020

My order was placed online at 6:47 pm. Their website gave me an estimated time of 1 hour. It's been an hour and a half, nothing but a busy signal on their phone. I understand it's Friday night,...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?

Grills (eating places), Bar (drinking places), Eating places

The Pizzeria

Founded in 1972, The Pizzeria in Gilboa, OH is a family-owned establishment run by brothers Brent and Curt Shafer. Renowned for their commitment to quality, they use only the freshest toppings and pride themselves on their time-honored pizza sauce recipe, which has remained unchanged since their inception. Baking their pizzas in traditional deck ovens, The Pizzeria emphasizes a superior quality product, favoring this method over quicker conveyor ovens. With a hands-on approach, Brent and Curt actively work alongside their dedicated staff, creating a welcoming community presence that has endeared them to local patrons. Generated from the website

Eating places, Italian restaurant

Padrone's Pizza

•

"Always excellent service and well worth the drive up from Cincinnati they are the best pizza and they have a phenomenal New York style pizza and the sauce is flavorful and the cheese is plentiful..."