Carrie P.
9/30/2025
This bakery has produced our daughter's favorite birthday cakes two years in a row. She has always been very particular about her birthday cakes. She takes their design very seriously and...
The Original Goodie Shop
$
Closed
(90)
Photos
2116 Tremont Ctr
Columbus, OH 43221
The Original Goodie Shop (Tremont Goodie Shop) is a full-line, family-owned bakery nestled in Upper Arlington, Ohio. For over 60 years, we’ve hand-made our products from scratch and served our customers – who are more like friends – with a smile. Our offering of baked goods covers every craving, from donuts to dinner rolls to cakes, cookies and more. You’ll be sure to find something that satisfies your senses.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.090 reviews
Mark K.
7/22/2025
I don't think I've been here before, though I might have been, decades ago. I didn't think Kid K had been here, but turns out she went with Sweetie last year. So, she kinda knew what to expect....
Don L.
6/8/2025
Big Donut Cakes! Try one of these rather than a standard birthday cake! I ordered online and didn't realize how big they are. One big donut cake and serve as much as a regular sized cake. 6-8 p
Marisa C.
12/11/2024
Okay first off, wow a donut for $2!! This bakery is no frills and sells you basic but good treats. I love glazed donuts, especially frosted ones. I ordered an original glazed donuts with chocolate...
Priyal P.
10/4/2025
We recently discovered this bakery and are in love! We ordered a Dino cake and some cookies for my son's bday party from here, and they did such an amazing job! We will be buying many cakes from...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.