Anissa G.
11/2/2025
Stopped into Sexton's and overall had a good experience! I ordered the pizza to go, and it took 20 minutes. We tried the deep dish, but honestly... not it, it was a little burnt. Now the thin...
Sexton's Pizza
Closed
(20)
Photos
5828 Evans Farm Dr
Lewis Center, OH 43035
Sexton's Pizza in Lewis Center, OH, is renowned for its artisan approach to pizza-making, featuring hand-tossed dough that undergoes a two-day rise for a perfectly airy crust. With a commitment to quality, this pizzeria proudly offers a variety of unique toppings and flavors that elevate each slice to a culinary experience, serving up delicious NYC-style pies from stone brick ovens.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.020 reviews
Marianne R.
10/7/2025
Stopped by on a Saturday afternoon. Nice sized covered patio and inside seating. Was greeted right away and waited on us as soon as we sat. He got the Smokey Robinson and myself the deep dish...
andy t.
6/27/2025
Love the pizza but it would have been much better hot. Ordered at the bar for carry out, gave them my phone number, got a text with the following message, "Your order has been placed in the...
Aubrey L.
10/7/2025
Their pizzas are so good and so big. They only come in one size but it's definitely a Large pizza. My friend and I just ordered the Mike! And the pesto pie with ricotta added. I don't think they...
Jocelyn H.
9/15/2025
Great pizza and service! I came to watch an OSU game and was able to find a seat on their patio which has three TVs and clean, comfortable tables. We got the Mike's Pizza which is not spicy...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.