Derek H.
11/10/2025
We keep ordering their pizza and it just simply never disappoints! We ordered our first pizza from them just a few months ago and now order at least twice a month. If you like a wonderful, firm,...
Sexton's Pizza
$$
Open
(109)
Photos
943 E Johnstown Rd
Columbus, OH 43230
Creno's Pizza Company is a well-established pizzeria chain in Central Ohio, boasting over 40 years of experience in perfecting their craft. Their commitment to quality is evident in their homemade spaghetti and pizza sauces, proprietary cheeses and meats, and fresh dough made daily without freezing.
The menu features a variety of options including traditional and specialty pizzas, subs, wings, calzones, and made-to-order salads. Creno's Pizza also offers catering services and values customer feedback, continuously striving for excellence while providing an authentic pizzeria experience.
Generated from the website
Find related places
Reviews
4.0109 reviews
Matthew H.
6/20/2025
This one was pretty straightforward. Atmosphere is what you would expect out of a new York style pizza shop. Smaller, slightly dated, and "dingy" but not gross by any means. It's exactly what I...
Alycia H.
9/11/2025
I ordered the East Village Pepperoni because it looked good -- plus it's the owner's favorite, so I figured it had to be worth it. I got it through Uber Eats, and while it did take about an hour...
Myra W.
7/11/2025
When I'm craving pizza, Sexton's hits the spot. It's yeasty and doughy with the right amount of wood burning char. The place isn't fancy - some booths. Paper plates, plastic etc but so yum....
Oli G.
12/7/2024
After having lunch at their nearby burger bar we wanted to try the full Sextons experience so we grabbed a pie for Sunday. After getting the pizza it looked so good so we tried a slice in the car....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.