Sharon L. W.
10/16/2025
Still a 5 star! Wings are big and juicy, Stromboli's are really delicious and pizzas have lots toppings to choose from to make it sooo good!
Plus One Pizza
$
Closed
(16)
Photos
618 Walnut St
Coshocton, OH 43812
Plus One Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant in Coshocton, OH, offering exceptional homemade dough, real Wisconsin cheese, and a wide variety of high-quality toppings. With their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, Plus One Pizza has been voted the best pizza in the area, guaranteeing a mouth-watering and satisfying dining experience.
As a Plus One Rewards Member, customers can earn points for every dollar spent, unlocking exclusive member-only offers and free food rewards. With their convenient mobile ordering app, customers can easily access the entire menu and earn reward points on the go. Whether it's a plain pizza or a unique signature creation, Plus One Pizza is the go-to destination for pizza lovers who never settle for anything less than outstanding quality.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.016 reviews
Gary R.
8/16/2024
Amazing! I can't say enough about how great this pizza is. Top notch taste and service.
Rebecca G.
2/8/2025
We always eat here when we visit my daughter and grandkids. They have the best Strombolis. They are fast too.
Belva L.
2/9/2022
This is our GO TO ALWAYS PIZZA SHOP!! We order Monday or Tuesday for their special- a carryout, 1 item large pizza! $8.55! We ALWAYS order Old World Pepperoni (it cups up when cooked & is a...
David R.
1/14/2023
We ordered pepperoni pizza, Greek salad and spicy garlic wings. They all tasted great! If we make it back to Coshocton in the future we would definitely order again.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.