Pizzeria New York

$
Closed
yelp logo

(53)

Call
Website

Photos

7950 E Broad St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43004
+1 (614) 868-3870
http://www.pizzerianewyork.com

Pizzeria New York brings authentic New York East Coast pizza to the Columbus area, with recipes dating back to 1969 from the Brooklyn Queens neighborhood.

Founded by a family from Queens, NY, Pizzeria New York offers a menu featuring New York style pizza, lunch and dinner entrees, salads, desserts, and more.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.053 reviews
Photo of John M.
John M.
5/19/2025

Very good subs, the pizza is awesome. I will definitely be ordering from here again in the future.

Read more on Yelp
Jared D.
8/15/2025

Honestly it's better than sextons. Great NY style pizza. I got pep and cheese. Service was quick and friendly. I would even say I like it Better than Brooklyn pizza in Powell. I'll definitely be...

Read more on Yelp
Brandon B.
5/7/2025

Food was great ! First pizza since moving to Ohio ! Was not disappointed ! Solid Italian sub as well.

Read more on Yelp
T Z.
5/16/2025

First timer here. This place (Broad St. location) is a hidden gem for NY-style pizza.. Reasonably priced for the quality. Excellent pizza--definitely worth a visit!

Read more on Yelp
Paige B.
4/5/2025

I have never had New York style pizza but this pizza was thin and chewy it was like it wasn't cooked all the way. I didn't really care for it. We got a few other items and they were not bad I just...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Pizza Hut
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Pizza Hut

15
"A shop of poor quality. I walked into the shop to pick up an order I'd placed online, only to be told that my pizzas were given to another customer. The cashier assured me that the new pizzas..."
Sbarro
Eating places, Pizza restaurants, Italian restaurant

Sbarro

2
•
$
"The pizza was great but the bacon cheddar bread was uncut and uncooked. The entire center of the bread was uncooked dough which is unfortunate because we were so excited to try it."
photo of Angela L.
Little Caesars
Pizza restaurants, Steak and barbecue restaurants

Little Caesars

$
Little Caesars in Reynoldsburg OH is a popular fast-food pizza chain known for its affordable prices and quick service. With a menu featuring classic pizzas Crazy Bread and innovative specialties this eatery offers a convenient option for families and pizza lovers on the go. Enjoy hot and ready pizzas perfect for any occasion! Generated from this place's information
United States›Ohio›Reynoldsburg›Pizzeria New York

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.