Jesse H.
6/27/2025
Best spot in New Carlisle for a quick bite , and coffee. Watch out for when it's busy.
Penny Lane Art Gallery & Coffee Shop
$
Open
(53)
Photos
109 S Main St
New Carlisle, OH 45344
Penny Lane Art Gallery Cafe is a charming establishment nestled in the heart of downtown New Carlisle, OH. With a focus on fresh and locally sourced ingredients, their made-to-order food menu offers a delightful selection of sandwiches, soups, desserts, and more. Additionally, their coffee beverages are expertly brewed using locally roasted beans from Boston Stoker, ensuring a rich and flavorful experience for all coffee enthusiasts.
At Penny Lane, visitors can unwind and enjoy a cup of coffee while surrounded by the cozy ambiance of the cafe. The establishment also doubles as an art gallery, showcasing beautiful canvas prints and offering a variety of other items such as candles. With daily specials posted on their Facebook page, Penny Lane invites patrons to join their community and share the love for their delectable offerings with friends and family.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.553 reviews
Keith M.
10/25/2025
Nice place to bring family and friends for a snack. The atmosphere is artsy but loud. Nice place for coffee and a small snack
Janki P.
10/7/2025
The place wasn't busy when I went, however it still took 25 minutes to make my iced latte. The person in line before me got his order of two iced drinks within 5 minutes so it felt kinda silly...
Haylee G.
5/31/2025
Coffee and sandwiches never disappoint! We typically go for the new flights and always find one we enjoy. 4 8oz drinks for $10.50 I believe. Baristas are always friendly and helpful with any...
Richard B.
9/21/2025
Lots of choices for drinks and food. This is one of our favorite coffee shops! Great ambiance with lots of local artwork.
See a problem?
