One More Time

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(55)

Call
Website

Photos

1521 W 5th Ave
Columbus, OH 43212
+1 (614) 486-0031
https://onemoretime.com

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, OH, One More Time is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by thrifters and vintage enthusiasts alike. This consignment shop exudes charm and character, offering a curated selection of pre-loved treasures that tell a story of their own. As you step inside, you're greeted by racks filled with unique clothing pieces, shelves adorned with eclectic home decor, and displays showcasing one-of-a-kind accessories.

One More Time invites you to embark on a treasure hunt where each visit promises new finds and hidden gems. The atmosphere is inviting, with friendly staff ready to assist you in uncovering that perfect piece to add to your collection. Whether you're on the hunt for a vintage statement piece or a trendy fashion find, this consignment shop in Columbus, OH, is a must-visit destination for those who appreciate the beauty of second-hand treasures.

Generated using this place's available information

Reviews

yelp logo
3.055 reviews
Photo of Christina M.
Christina M.
11/29/2021

I'd give the clothing store of One More Time 3.5 stars, if half stars were possible. They have a pretty large store in Grandview with multiple rooms, and they are one of the few consignment stores...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of M J.
M J.
8/27/2025

I had one of the most disappointing retail experiences at this store. I came in with authentic designer shoes, only to be met with rude, judgmental treatment from the owner, Chris. Without...

Read more on Yelp
Ganelle M.
12/5/2024

Very well organized and clean! Creative displays with name brands, in great condition, with reasonable prices!!! Tons of jewelry that is soooo affordable, I brought home 10 pair of earrings!

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Lara H.
Lara H.
10/7/2019

You can find a lot of hidden gems at One More Time, but you do have to be in the mood to browse through lots of duds. I find their pricing better than other consignment stores in this area, which...

Read more on Yelp
Alex S.
6/24/2020

To echo what one of the other reviews mentioned, the owner is not focused on customer service whatsoever. I had sold some items to them at the beginning of the year and chose to receive store...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Plato's Closet
Women's specialty clothing stores, Clothing and shoes, secondhand, Office furniture and store fixtures, secondhand

Plato's Closet

16
•
$
"This is about shopping Men's items only. I found several items that were of a good value, including shoes. After a different experience not far away, it was a pleasant surprise to find things not..."
photo of Tom H.
Plato's Closet
Women's specialty clothing stores, Clothing and shoes, secondhand, Office furniture and store fixtures, secondhand

Plato's Closet

30
•
$$
"So......Plato's Closet: some of their items are a bit over priced for a second hand shop. HOWEVER, the actual name brand items that my teen has to have: reasonable and gently used. There are..."
photo of Tabitha F.
Twenty Four Exchange
Eating places, Women's specialty clothing stores, Custom and orthopedic shoes

Twenty Four Exchange

3
•
$$
"American greasy fare, frozen/fried food joint. Growing up near Hillsboro, we always wanted an option for more fun... insert 24 Deli and Pizza. Once a consignment shop turned Deli, this location..."
photo of Rebecca M.
United States›Ohio›Columbus›One More Time

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.