Brian N.
8/23/2025
Picked up a peach and blueberry pie today at the market in Bexley after preordering online. Have been searching for a long time for first rate pie. I have finally found it in Ohio Pies. Filling...
Ohio Pies
Open
(15)
Photos
Columbus, OH 43215
Ohio Pies is a licensed home bakery in Columbus, OH, dedicated to creating handmade pies using locally-sourced, organic ingredients. With a strong commitment to supporting the local economy and environment, the owner and baker, Emily Irvine, goes the extra mile to ensure the best quality pies while nourishing the community. Whether it's hand pies, mini pies, or whole pies, Ohio Pies aims to feed your soul with flaky, buttery, and delicious creations.
With no storefront, Ohio Pies can be found at local farmers markets from April to December, at Bexley Natural Market every Friday, or you can conveniently order whole pies directly. Praised by Chef Andy Dubyoski as the "single best bite of pie," Ohio Pies' mission is to provide a beautiful reflection of the community through their homemade pies.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.515 reviews
Christina D.
11/28/2022
The apple crumb pie was amazing, and reminded me of my grandma's apple cake, stuffed full of cinnamon and apple flavor. I also got the maple pecan pie, which was a little too sweet for me - it's...
Marissa C.
10/18/2021
We came across Ohio Pies at the Pearl Market, where the booth was absolutely hopping! I think we pretty much all went "Oooo Pie!" to one another and then we promptly went over to peruse the menu...
Gwen W.
7/23/2019
Was introduced to Ohio Pies while perusing the Pearl Market. Tried a sample of their Buckeye Pie, and whao. WHAOOOOOOO :D that's some top sh**! I'm pretty sure I heard the gal right that the pie...
Lakie F.
11/4/2023
i got a handheld pie and my partner and i split it and it was so yummy! the right level of sweetness and you can tell it was made with love! yay!
See a problem?
