Nickalena's

Open
yelp logo

(2)

Call

Photos

209 W Bigelow Ave
Plain City, OH 43064
+1 (614) 873-0780

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.02 reviews
Photo of Lori K.
Lori K.
10/7/2025

Fantastic pizza! We went for the lunch buffet - the crispie crust and the sauce were delicious. Note: the building is a split level - Lee's Sports & Spirits on top Nickalena's in the lower...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mark K.
Mark K.
10/2/2025

This place has been half a dozen different pizza joints since I lived out here 15 years ago. This newest one I can't quite figure out. It says Nickalena's, and on their Facebook page it says...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza
Eating places, Barbecue restaurant

Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

1
"We live about 20 mins away from this restaurant, but had seen it come highly recommended on one of our local FB pages, so we thought we'd give it a try because we are never overly impressed with..."
photo of Melissa E.
Pioneer Pizza
Eating places

Pioneer Pizza

45
•
$
"Not sure why it's only 3,5 stars. The chicken wings and Stromboli are always good! Lots of homemade souse with it too. Love it!"
Plain City Lanes Pizza
Eating places, Restaurant, family: chain

Plain City Lanes Pizza

13
•
$$
"Small town fun! This place reminds me of growing up. Back when my parents were in a bowling league. It's not modern at all and that makes it all the better. The staff is friendly, it's clean and..."
photo of Danielle H.
United States›Ohio›Plain City›Nickalena's