Michelle O.
8/9/2025
Went to Artisan Craft Meadery. Had a nice time and drank mead and had a pizza. That place rocks! See that review. Then asked the bartender for a local ice cream recommendation. She told us here....
New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream
$
Closed
(24)
Photos
14738 Ravenna Ave NE
Hartville, OH 44601
Located in the charming town of Hartville, OH, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a delightful spot to satisfy your sweet cravings. Nestled among quaint shops and cozy cafes, this ice cream shop stands out for its mouthwatering array of handcrafted frozen treats. Step inside and be greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly made waffle cones and the cheerful chatter of fellow ice cream enthusiasts.
From classic flavors like creamy vanilla and decadent chocolate to innovative creations such as honey lavender and maple bacon, there's a scoop for every palate at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream. Whether you're strolling through town on a sunny day or seeking a cozy dessert spot in the evening, this charming ice cream shop offers a scoop of happiness in every cone.
Generated using this place's available information
Reviews
4.024 reviewsTrina C.
9/7/2025
The ice cream flavors are fresh and homemade, with specialty flavors every week. The staff is very friendly and courteous! I wish they were open year- round!!
Pamela A.
10/6/2024
New Baltimore ice cream is the best in Ohio and we drive miles just to get there. Even the small cone is big enough to fill my appetite and any one looking for a delicious treat. Customer service...
Jennifer T.
10/7/2019
Walk up window that takes cash. What are the flavors....they change. Yup! Handmade real deal yall. It is worth every penny. And they also serve ice cream for fur babies as to which we saw a 4...
David M.
4/23/2023
Awesome place. Period! Service, variety, atmosphere...it checks all the boxes. Great for the kids, parents and grandparents.
See a problem?
