Steve T.
11/24/2025
The drunken mussels are great. A good amount of mussels and the sub bun as bread sticks was a surprise sand toasted perfectly.
Muddy's
$$
Closed
(106)
Photos
335 E Liberty St
Wooster, OH 44691
Muddy's is a popular hangout spot located in downtown Wooster, Ohio, originally known as Muddy Waters Cafe when it began over 15 years ago. Since its acquisition by Dennis and Paula Tafoya in 2005, the establishment has grown from an initial focus on expansion to a dedicated commitment to its current location, offering a welcoming atmosphere for locals.
Under the Tafoyas' leadership, Muddy's has evolved significantly, highlighted by the opening of Muddy's Waters Cafe and Grille in 2010 as one of Ohio's first Entertainment Districts. In 2015, they settled into a historic setting in the former Art Bucher Cadillac Dealership, solidifying Muddy's place in the community's heritage.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.5106 reviews
Taylor T.
5/14/2025
Have been here many times. A friend goes here every week & multiple times. She loves the food & drinks.. I personally only like the mixed drink I always get. The food I have ate here maaaybe 3...
Bob N.
9/28/2025
As a former brewery owner, and a lover of Fathead's beers, we ordered an Octoberfest beer and received a light lagerish beer. When we challenged the bartender, she confirmed that it was indeed the...
Doug R.
4/18/2025
Great place with really diverse menu, great local beers on tap and set in a really cool atmosphere. We went after a College of Wooster Softball game as the Visiting Team from DePauw with family...
Brad W.
12/6/2024
Waited over an hour. Asked the server that appeared to be taking care of the whole restaurant by herself. She said that the chicken just came up in the window after an hour and 15 minute wait....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.