DoorDashed pizza tonight. I've had Mikey's before but never ordered a full pizza. DoorDash had a buy-one-get-one free pizza so I decided to grab pizza tonight. I landed on two pepperoni and...
Mikey's Late Night Slice
$
Closed
(304)
Photos
1030 N High St
Columbus, OH 43201
A Columbus favorite, Late Night Slice offers big floppy slices of delicious pizza, 24 flavors of Faygo, and irreverently titled specialty items such as The Cheezus Crust, The Baby Cheezus, and The Pizza Dawg!
Also at this address
Reviews
Brent W.
8/31/2025
Paul N.
6/11/2025
Everyone said it would be hard to find good NY style pizza in Columbus. As a native New Yorker, I approve of this pizza. The spicy sauce is incredible, you owe it to yourself to try it!
D L.
6/3/2025
Just very good. And I am a hard critic. Late night slice, when visiting Oddfellows campus. It's just garlic and basil.... Shockingly good. Namaste.
Mark R.
11/22/2024
For good pizza I would not come here. The scene is cool, though the signs of drunken college kids abound (I.e. watch where you step!)... service was super nice.
Eve R.
4/20/2024
I don't care what anybody says. Mikey's is a solid slice. Gone are the days of a cheap slice and curb sittin but I won't complain because it's fun and quick and the mushroom is as good now as it...
Owner verified
See a problem?







