Ben R.
10/11/2025
Apple crunch & Dutch apple pies were amazing--local gem! 5/5, highly recommend. Go there to get good pies
Mehaffies Pies
$
Closed
(45)
Photos
3013 Linden Ave
Dayton, OH 45410
Mehaffies Pies, located in Dayton, Ohio, has been a beloved bakery since 1930, specializing in the finest pies and cheesecakes the state has to offer. With a commitment to freshness, they bake their products daily, ensuring a delightful experience for every customer.
In addition to their delicious offerings, Mehaffies Pies also engages in community initiatives, such as the Pie Peddler program, which raises funds for various good causes. Their dedication to quality and community makes them a cherished establishment in the Dayton area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.545 reviews
Ron H.
1/20/2025
Watching a program on Boston foods, a section on Boston Cream pies led us back to Mehaffies Pies for Sunday desserts. Upon a change in ownership, we saw that the formula for the chocolate icing...
A. R.
9/8/2025
It used to be GREAT .. not so anymore the crust recipe clearly has changed .. not good. I have been coming here since this place opened such a disappointment guess I should have bailed when the...
KD G.
6/29/2025
Been in business for a super long time! Highly recommend their cheesecake with a side of cherries to top the cheesecake....oh so goooood! You can't go wrong with any of their freshly made pies!...
Judy D.
6/8/2024
I bought a Mehaffies strawberry rhubarb pie at Fulton Farms today, and wow. What a massive disappointment. The crust is soft, yet tough & crumbly, tasteless, and too thick. There is very little...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.