Sue T.
7/14/2022
This is one of the best local ice cream spots in town. Not only that, it holds a lot of historical value to Akron, OH. Come here for generously sized sundaes and THE BEST peanut butter pie ever....
Mary Coyle Ice Cream
$
Closed
(102)
Photos
780 W Market St
Akron, OH 44303
Trecaso's Mary Coyle Ice Cream offers a delicious blend of Italian cuisine and delectable sweet treats in Akron, OH. Specializing in pizza, pasta, and a variety of ice cream and candy options, the establishment prides itself on serving unique dishes made from their signature crust.
In addition to savoring the tasty food, customers can choose from an array of gifts, including gift certificates and fun novelty items like the Goodyear Blimp stress reliever. This family-friendly destination captures the essence of traditional ice cream parlors while delivering exceptional dining experiences.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.0102 reviews
Aedan F.
10/12/2025
Had a terrible experience with the customer service and was shocked to find out that the old man behind the bar is the owner of this shop. He represents the cute atmosphere and mediocre ice cream...
Daniel C.
4/20/2025
Uncomfortable That's what I'm gonna say.. So many rules just to get a milkshake . I think the owner is burned out after all the years of working .
Ismael R.
7/8/2025
owner made everyone wait outside, place is more often than not closed, grumpy, ice cream is just ok, but the business is way past its prime, great location, but service is not .
Nicholas M.
2/23/2025
Best ice cream I've ever had! Service was great. It's a little bit like dicks last resort. Some people don't get the owners sense of humor... but I promise he is a really great guy. I've been...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.