Marla R.
6/5/2025
This is a hidden gem. Lindsey's birthday cakes are perfection. My grandsons tractor cake, complete with Oreo "dirt" was best! Their cakes already taste better than any grocery store cake so the...
Lindsey's Bakery
$
Open
(71)
Photos
127 W Main St
Circleville, OH 43113
Lindsey's Bakery in Circleville, OH offers a wide range of delicious cakes and baked goods for customers to enjoy. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, the bakery provides a welcoming atmosphere for visitors to indulge in sweet treats.
Customers can find inspiration in the bakery's cake gallery and explore various options to satisfy their cravings. Lindsey's Bakery is dedicated to providing a memorable experience for all who walk through its doors.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.571 reviews
Joseph S.
12/14/2024
I can't believe I forgot to review this AMAZING place when I noticed the photos on my phone. I went during the pumpkin show and my advise is to go early or not during the show because in my...
Demetrius B.
8/27/2024
Circleville is Central Ohio's undisputed pumpkin capital, but the pumpkin donut at Lindsey's (sold year round) was just okay for me. They have cut out cookies, which I wouldn't get again, and a...
John C.
11/1/2024
This is a small town bakery that capitalized big time on the towns "Pumpkin Show". During Pumpkin Show the bakery is mobbed inside and out to see their biggest pumpkin pie. A 4'-5' behemoth. Their...
Scott D.
10/20/2023
Home of the world's largest pumpkin pie! Pumpkin donuts are good too, cake style, light pumpkin spice flavor, light glaze. During the pumpkin show, expect a line half a block long to get a piece...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.