Slaphappy P.
8/2/2023
THIS is the kind of pizza I have been searching for in Columbus for years. A thin crust, but not the kind that turns into a soda cracker. It's still soft. Perfect sauce, not overwhelmed with...
Josie's Pizza
$
Closed
(39)
Photos
3205 W Broad St
Columbus, OH 43204
Josie's Pizza, located in Columbus, Ohio, has a rich history rooted in Italian tradition, stemming from the Catalfina family, who immigrated from Sicily in 1920. Known for their unique approach to pizza, they place pepperoni underneath the cheese to enhance flavor and create a traditional Italian pizza experience.
In addition to their signature pepperoni pizza, Josie's offers a variety of menu items, including Italian subs, spicy pepperoni, chicken wings, and calzones, all made with homemade dough and fresh ingredients. The restaurant prides itself on delivering a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.039 reviewsMark W.
4/24/2025
My girlfriend and I are doing the Columbus pizza trail this year and Josie's Hilltop is on the list. For starter's the place was incredibly warm, like 85 degrees inside. Maybe we caught them on...
Christina L.
9/23/2024
Ordering and pick up was easy . Everyone was friendly . Nice little spot tucked away off broad street ample parking and the food was superior .
Justin T.
7/10/2024
This place is the best. Get the calzone, trust me. Shoutout to Sue for working the lunch shift by herself!
Lucas S.
2/8/2025
"Wow" all the way around! Very friendly service, quick preparation, and delicious flavorful pizza. I can see why they've been in business over 60 years! Will be returning!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.