Lisa M.
5/8/2024
The food was really good. Baked Rotoni was amazing. You can tell this is the local.hangout for all ages. The girls that served us were kind enough to tell us the difference between Cinci chili...
Jim's Pizza Box
$
Closed
(87)
Photos
10 N Main St
Milan, OH 44846
Jims Pizza Box is an Italian restaurant and pizza shop that has been serving Milan, Ohio for over sixty years. We are locally owned and operated. We credit our delicious cuisine to the time-tested recipes of our matriarch, Momma Josephine. Her Italian-American recipes are still served in our kitchens today. Most notably her pizza and pasta sauces, homemade soups, and comfort food specials. Whether youre in the mood for pizza with a flaky, crisp crust and a soft bread dough interior or subs, baked on fresh bread with meats that makes your mouth water Jims Pizza Box is the place for you. Swing by or call in your order and enjoy a true taste of Italy today.
Reviews
5.087 reviewsCora T.
7/11/2025
The pizza was burnt. It was done on the inside. The toppings were next to nothing. You couldn't even tell there was any sauce on it. I was very very disappointed. I all the way from Fremont to...
Renee L.
6/18/2025
The crust was good. The issue we had is they put colby cheese on top of every pizza (or in the calzones). We thought we'd give it a try but learned it is simply not for us. The flavor of colby...
Kendra L.
5/26/2024
We arrived at 7:00 on a Friday night expecting a wait, since the Yelp reviews are SO good. We were shocked to find the restaurant had hardly anyone inside. We stayed and are glad we did! The...
Calvin C.
10/17/2023
Visiting and heard about this local spot in Milan. Apparently the owner is well-established in the community and supports the local high schools! Only ordered a large calzone but wish I also got...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.