Emily G.
8/25/2025
Always, always worth a visit. Phenomenal locally made ice cream in flavors both classic and avant garde. Ditch tea delight (think mint chocolate chip but fudgier; I believe it has Oreos in it) is...
Hartzler Family Dairy
$
Closed
(85)
Photos
5454 Cleveland Rd
Wooster, OH 44691
Hartzler Family Dairy opened in 1996 to sell dairy "As Nature Intended". We sell low-temperature vat pasteurized, non-homogenized milk products, including flavored milk, butter, cheese, and ice cream. We have a selection of 24 ice cream flavors at our shop. We also have a coffee menu that features standard drip coffee, along with espresso drinks that highlight the versatility of our dairy (and a killer affogato).
Reviews
4.585 reviews
Kelsey J.
7/9/2025
One of my favorite places in all of Ohio! I've been coming here since I was a little girl! This is one of my favorite flavors! Hot mud! Hartzler's has the BEST ice cream!
Lisa T.
8/14/2024
Still some of the best ice cream in the USA! Yes I said it ad it's true! So creamy! Always good flavors always fresh and get some cream top milk and some cheese as well! You won't regret it!
Promethieus V.
4/6/2025
NEED VANILLA GALLON I been had the chocolate and it is so mf good man but the god sent vanilla is only in such a puenty 12oz bottle this makes me upset that I can't consume abnormal amounts of...
J T.
5/11/2024
Best ice cream from local spot. Super nice service and amazing atmosphere. Must go place
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.