Ken M.
10/2/2025
Very pleasantly surprised! I enjoyed a "large" slice of "The Don" pizza while I watched them hand-toss the dough. I then grabbed a slice of cheesecake and a cannoli (to die for!) and headed to...
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North
Closed
(14)
Photos
608 N High St
Columbus, OH 43215
Goodfellas Short North brings hand-tossed NY-style slices and pies (12", 16", 22") with stone-baked crusts, calzones, and breadsticks, plus a full bar. Crowd favorites include the $10 Lunch Special, Tommy “Two Times,” Taste of Naples, and ½-price 12" Mondays. Private event rentals with a private bar and the Wiseguy Lounge bourbon list. Dine-in and carryout, open late. Steps from the Short North Arts District, Greater Columbus Convention Center, Goodale Park, and Victorian/Italian Village. Vegetarian options. Events/Catering: office@goodfellaspizzeria.com
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.514 reviews
Brian W.
7/29/2025
Service is terrific, with friendly and welcoming staff, combined with ample seating and a great location at the south end of Short North. The pizza, tho, is entirely average for a pizzeria in...
Melissa R.
7/12/2025
As far as the food goes, it was excellent. On a 1-10 scale I'd easily give it a 9.5 Service...we came after a concert. They close at 12. We made it at 1150. Along with ten other people. They let...
Kerri F.
9/29/2025
Pizza was really good. The team was super friendly and I had no issues. Good variety of pizza by this slice. Music was super cool and the Lounge in the back of the building look like a lot of fun....
Mike L.
6/19/2025
Order time 7:39, pickup estimate 8:10. Arrived 8:00. Buffalo chicken cheese bread Crust 10/10 Sauce & cheese 10/10 Chicken 5/10, taste like it's out of a gfs bag Served fresh, hot; right from the...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
