Gem City Pizza

$
Closed
yelp logo

(8)

Call
Website

Photos

901 Franklin St
Toronto, OH 43964
+1 (740) 337-4551
https://www.facebook.com

Step into Gem City Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Toronto, Ohio. This cozy spot offers a taste of Ohio Valley's finest pizza, perfect for satisfying those cravings for a delicious slice. Whether you're in the mood for traditional tray pizza or craving the unique charm of square pizza, this eatery has something to delight every pizza lover's palate.

Don't miss out on their standout creation, the Swagger Sauce—a patented dipping sauce that adds an extra punch of flavor to your pizza experience. When searching for pizza near you in Toronto, Ohio, Gem City Pizza stands out among the array of restaurants, promising a delightful culinary adventure for both locals and visitors alike.

Generated using this place's available information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.58 reviews
Gary M.
8/23/2025

Got pizza here after the football game. It was my first time in years , I had moved and been back about 5 years now. WOW! This pizza was excellent. Got just the right amount of spice to it and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Lynn C.
Lynn C.
10/11/2024

We ordered takeout from here a few weeks ago after seeing a Facebook post. We have driven by here a few times and decided to try. We ordered a tray and a Buffalo chicken canzone. The pizza was...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Scott M.
Scott M.
10/7/2017

Visited a Gem City Pizza in Myrtle Beach, SC, several years ago. Loved it and visited several times during vacation. Learned that the owners were from Toronto OH. So when I came thru Toronto on...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Gary R.
Gary R.
4/30/2015

I been coming here for a long time... Myself I think this is the best pizza in toronto. why only 4 star is becuase of the crust.. the dough part has kind of a heavy taste to it.. I like my crust a...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Derek W.
Derek W.
8/6/2017

Gem city pizza is the best pizza around, that's saying something considering in a 4 mile radius we have nothing but pizza places, great service, fast delivery & cheap prices. I Highly recommend...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Domino's Pizza
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Domino's Pizza

4
•
$
"What can you say about chain store pizza ? Toronto has DiCarlos, they make awesome pizza, the best in town.. I hate most of the Domino's Pizza'a but the thin crust is to die for, Thin crispy and..."

Mama G's Pizza

8
•
$
"I ordered to pick-up...they said 20min...got there in 15min figuring I'd have to wait...no pizza is on top of oven, so I got it home an its stone cold...THIS IS PIZZA THAT DOESN'T TASTE GOOD..."
photo of Lynda Y.
Domino's Pizza
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Domino's Pizza

8
•
$
"UPDATE! The franchise owner came me himself to apologize for everything. He is also calling Dakota. He couldn't believe an employee of his restaurant would do such a thing. He is sending a check..."
United States›Ohio›Toronto›Gem City Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.