Tash M.
8/15/2025
This is a long standing local operation, and it's a breakfast/pizza/bar all in one. We came for breakfast, which was a nice and peaceful vibe, which was greatly needed after an evening of island...
Frosty Bar
$$
Closed
(135)
Photos
252 Delaware Ave
Put in Bay, OH 43456
Frosty Bar is proud to serve island visitors and locals for more than 60 years. Whether you’re hungry for a pizza, thirsty for a cold beer, or looking for the best breakfast on Put-in-Bay, Frosty’s is a great place to gather, socialize, and enjoy the island atmosphere.
Reviews
3.5135 reviews
Zach G.
5/17/2025
The flavor of the pizza was good, but the crust honestly reminded me of a cardboard insert from a frozen pizza... there was also so much cheese that every bite the toppings would come off. The...
Billy L.
5/8/2025
We were at Put-in-Bay before the busy season and I think this was the only place open for breakfast. The waitress was very sweet and they had enough options for breakfast, but they weren't able to...
Cara R.
5/11/2025
Frostys has been a tradition. I'm from Ottawa county so it's an institution. It used to be the affordable place with terrible pizza that soaked up the days alcohol. Today we went and ordered 1...
Kelly K.
7/8/2024
Bacon egg and cheese on croissant was delicious! Thankfully they served breakfast cause on Monday and Tuesdays , nothing else was open for indoor dining at 8am
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.