Keith H.
7/18/2025
Outstanding pizza and excellent customer service!!!! Always consistently good! Best pizza in Bellefontaine!!!
Fat Boy's Pizza & Ice Cream
$$
Closed
(21)
Photos
2527 US Highway 68 S Ste 4
Bellefontaine, OH 43311
Fat Boy's Pizza & Ice Cream Provides Pizza, Subs, Salads, Appetizer, Gyros, Wings, Bread Items And Award Winning Homemade Brand Ice Cream To The Bellefontaine, OH Area. Pizza Buffet from: Wednesday 5:00 PM-7:30 PM, Friday 11:00 AM-2:00 PM, Sunday 12:00 NN-3:00 PM. Voted by Zagat, Best Pizza in Bellefontaine for 2 years by Zagat Rating System
Also at this address
Reviews
4.021 reviews
Nicki B.
7/26/2025
We love Fat Boys pizza. We quit ordering for awhile because toppings were no where near the edge. And the price was one of the highest around. Which we don't mind paying for quality but can't...
Jared S.
3/5/2023
Parking: Parking lot is half asphalt and half gravel. Always tons of parking spots available Seating: Most people seems to buy carry-out, but if you want to sit and eat there, they have plenty of...
Aaron A.
6/29/2024
Fat Boys Pizza... The only thing better than taking a pizza pie home from here, is living into their buffet! We carried out from here and the pizza was great. Had to get extra sauce, bc why not,...
Michael W.
8/7/2024
Very good pizza, but I don't recommend reheating! I feel it is a bit pricey for pizza.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.