Sheila J.
6/26/2025
very good ice cream and friendly people that run that place to I love to go there thank you Sheila jones
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
$
Open
(8)
Photos
18 Pleasant St
Wakeman, OH 44889
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop is a small, bustling ice cream parlor located in the heart of Wakeman, Ohio. Owned and operated by Keely Krumwiede, a former teacher, the shop offers a delectable selection of premium, small-batch ice cream made with a 15% butterfat mix for an exceptionally creamy and rich taste.
With a commitment to quality, Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop produces their own ice cream in a dairy processing barn at the Krumwiede family farm just outside of Wakeman. This allows them to create unique flavors and experiment with new ingredients, ensuring that every scoop or container is a delicious treat.
Generated from the website
Reviews
5.08 reviews
Rachel R.
9/2/2023
Love this place! I come here often. The ice cream is delicious, home made, hand packed (or soft serve) in flavors and combinations no one else has. They even sell ice cream pies! Friendly staff-...
Amanda M.
11/23/2020
Cute ice cream shop with large portions Heard about this little shop right off the main drag. Ice cream is really good and portions are good size. We bought kiddie cones for $2 and easily enough...
Rob B.
1/13/2023
Great helado made by the owner. It is an unexpected gem in the small village. The staff rocks.
Tiffany M.
4/20/2022
We love Cream of the Crop! Everything we have had so far has been delicious! Everyone always has a smile too!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.