Anthony C.
8/30/2025
The pizza here is top tier. I have had several different, but the Margherita is delish with fresh mozzarella and basil. My go to is the pepperoni with extra cheese. They have live music and fun...
Cameo Pizza
$$
Open
(48)
Photos
272 Delaware Ave
Put in Bay, OH 43456
Cameo Pizza in Put-in-Bay has been a family tradition since 1936, located inside Mr. Ed’s bar on Delaware Avenue. Whether you're in for lunch, dinner, or late-night treats, this spot offers a fantastic menu featuring specialty pizzas, cheesy bread, subs, nachos, salads, and more.
What sets Cameo Pizza apart is its commitment to quality. Using a secret family recipe for their pizza sauce and dough perfected in Sandusky, Ohio, over 62 years ago, they ensure that only the freshest and top-quality ingredients are used in every pizza they make. With 100% real cheese, vine-ripened tomatoes, and the best herbs and spices, their pizzas are a treat for the taste buds.
For added convenience, Cameo Pizza offers delivery anywhere on Put-in-Bay until 3 am daily, making it the go-to late-night pizza spot for locals and visitors alike. From the Island Club home rentals to the South Bass Island State Park and Campground, their delivery service ensures that everyone can enjoy their delicious pizzas at any time.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.548 reviews
Barbara S.
6/28/2024
We were so glad to find a place here on the island that delivered. The pizza was so good! And the service was excellent! I'm sure that the ambiance of the restaurant is also good. Highly recommend...
Kate W.
5/14/2025
best chicken alfredo pizza i've ever had! love the chicken alfredo pizza! if you stop by, you should definitely try out the new chicken alfredo pizza, i love it!
Rachel K.
7/30/2024
Some quick searching led us to believe that this might be the only place in Put-in-Bay that delivers, so I will admit that's why we picked it. However, it was a great choice!! We got the hot honey...
Steph M.
7/8/2023
We loved the pizza here ! Definitely would recommend and would order every time we visit put -in bay
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.