Sharon J.
10/22/2025
If I could give CC 10 stars I would! Our family has ordered cakes from them for years - always very satisfied. Cakes are moist and delicious. And expertly and appropriately decorated. Best...
Cake Creations
$
Closed
(16)
Photos
11140 Milton Carlisle Rd
New Carlisle, OH 45344
Also at this address
Reviews
4.516 reviewsMaureena M.
8/22/2023
The baked good are always so good. Friendly people. Pleasant atmosphere. Prices are very reasonable which is awesome in this horrible economy we have now. Delicious cakes and cookies
Nickey P.
6/18/2023
They have the best cakes cupcakes and brownies. The employees are always friendly and helpful if you have a special order! Will always get my cakes and treats from here!!!
Taylor S.
7/4/2021
Best cake ever! I stopped in for cookies (their oatmeal raisin is the best) and decided on a whim to order my daughter's birthday cake. Not only did they do a great job decorating it, it was also...
Stacy S.
4/17/2019
My brother heard of this little place and was dying to try a cake so he got one for my birthday. It was good but I wouldn't say the best cake I've ever had. Now that he and my parents both live...
See a problem?
