Chaya F.
4/18/2025
Love the pizza. Everything about it tastes great. I believe that the flavor of the sause is unique. I wish they would stay open later.
Bexley Pizza Plus
$
Closed
(98)
Photos
2651 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209
Bexley Pizza Plus is a renowned pizzeria in Columbus, OH, known for its commitment to using only the best ingredients, including fresh dough, real cheese, and homemade sauce prepared with vine-ripened tomatoes.
With a wide variety of toppings and 24 signature specialty pizzas, every order is prepared to order, ensuring a delicious and satisfying experience. The pizzeria's out-of-this-world crust, made with their signature homemade dough, is a favorite among both thick and thin crust pizza connoisseurs.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.098 reviews
Robin F.
6/29/2025
Best pizza in Columbus! Delivery is great! I always have to remember to ask them to pie slice my pizza not in little squares. They also have the best brownies!
Shelia R.
9/9/2025
I am so disappointed with Bexley Pizza, I ordered a peperoni pizza that had very little peperoni on the LARGE PIZZA they admitted that they cut back on the ingredients and upped the price. That...
John B.
7/25/2025
Over priced !!! Charging 1095 for a small side salad calling it. A chef salad literally had three pepperonis, three tomatoes and a pinch of black olives what a joke
Phoebe S.
7/20/2025
This is one of my go-to places for pizza and for meeting with a friend or two for lunch -- lots of sitting space, no rushing, and good parking. As for the pizza, I've tried both plain cheese and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.