Ryan C.
10/18/2025
I llllove a good Margherita pizza, and Bexley Pizza Plus didnt let me down. Chill vibe here, sat outside and enjoyed my pie (doused in parmesano and chili flakes ofc ). They made it fast and...
Bexley Pizza Plus
$
Closed
(100)
Photos
2651 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209
Bexley Pizza Plus is a renowned pizzeria in Columbus, OH, known for its commitment to using only the best ingredients, including fresh dough, real cheese, and homemade sauce prepared with vine-ripened tomatoes.
With a wide variety of toppings and 24 signature specialty pizzas, every order is prepared to order, ensuring a delicious and satisfying experience. The pizzeria's out-of-this-world crust, made with their signature homemade dough, is a favorite among both thick and thin crust pizza connoisseurs.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0100 reviewsMelissa J.
11/7/2025
Walked in and was greeted first thing by multiple gentlemen. They have a cute small dining area that had 2 TVs and a fountain soda machine. Let me tell you that they have some of the most...
Robin F.
6/29/2025
Best pizza in Columbus! Delivery is great! I always have to remember to ask them to pie slice my pizza not in little squares. They also have the best brownies!
John B.
7/25/2025
Over priced !!! Charging 1095 for a small side salad calling it. A chef salad literally had three pepperonis, three tomatoes and a pinch of black olives what a joke
Shelia R.
9/9/2025
I am so disappointed with Bexley Pizza, I ordered a peperoni pizza that had very little peperoni on the LARGE PIZZA they admitted that they cut back on the ingredients and upped the price. That...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.