Denver G.
10/6/2025
Top notch!!! Friendly, excellent selection, and delicious food and drinks!!! We were just passing through, but won't forget the experience! Keep reaching for the stars!!!!! DenverG
8 Sisters Bakery
$
Open
(132)
Photos
6200 State Route 95 # 300
Mount Gilead, OH 43338
8 Sisters Bakery, founded in 2010 by Emma Schwartz Lister, offers a delectable array of Amish-style baked goods in Mount Gilead, OH. Named after the 8 Schwartz sisters, the bakery prides itself on using top-quality ingredients and traditional baking methods to create a variety of pastries, cakes, and custom desserts.
With two convenient locations, 8 Sisters Bakery provides a charming atmosphere filled with the sweet aroma of freshly baked treats. Whether dining in or opting for carryout, customers can indulge in a wide selection of seasonal and holiday-themed goodies, all made with a commitment to excellence and a motto of "You Name It, We Bake It."
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5132 reviews
David A.
10/14/2025
Absolutely fantastic. Glad that I had to stop to charge my car. Doubt that I would've ever found this place otherwise. Now I need to figure out a way or a reason to come back. The pastries are...
Patrick P.
9/13/2024
Let me just say: 8 Sisters Bakery has the bestest donuts. I travel to Pittsburgh frequently and stop by to grab a couple dozen. I've been feeding my team of engineers these glorious pastries,...
Patrick G.
6/15/2025
So, so good! Stopped here on a trip up to Cleveland. I had never heard of it, but saw it in a highway sign. It's a small place, but full of charm and great food. There is no seating inside and...
Michael F.
10/19/2025
Amazing fresh and tasty pastries! The best cream stick/long John I've ever had. The bear claw and cinnamon twists were very good too.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.