J H.
10/6/2025
I always love eating their Stromboli. I call it in for pickup like once a week the only problem is the time it takes to cook and the price but it's still damn good viddles
The Original Papa Nick's
$$
Open
(113)
Photos
15 College St
Mars Hill, NC 28754
The Original Papa Nick's, situated in Mars Hill, NC, has been a staple for over five decades, delighting patrons with homestyle Italian cuisine. As a family-owned establishment, they emphasize top-notch ingredients and exceptional service, inviting guests to experience their culinary legacy firsthand.
From their inviting dining room to their convenient take-out options, Papa Nick's offers a diverse menu that caters to a range of tastes and preferences. Whether you're craving a classic pizza or exploring their Italian specialties, each dish is crafted with care and tradition, promising a satisfying dining experience.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
4.5113 reviewsJ T.
9/26/2025
Ordered online at least an hour ahead as we were in no hurry. 1.5 hrs later checked in at the carry out area and were told two minutes. 20 minutes later checked in again and were told "we don't...
Lesley P.
9/20/2024
My friends and I are spending a few days in Mars Hill and stumbled across The Original Papa Nick's and decided to give it a try, and I am so glad we did. We went on a Friday night and the indoor...
Danny S.
8/24/2025
I am very disappointed to find out they're now closed on Sundays it was the go to after church place but I won't be back now that's the only day I have interest in pizza sorry but yall lost a customer
Christina C.
7/1/2024
Our trip to Mars Hill wasn't supposed to involve a stop here, but sometimes things don't work out how you planned. We were in town on a Wednesday and little did we know the place we wanted to go...
See a problem?
