Mady J.
8/12/2025
Very well may be my new favorite pizza place. Slight crunch with each bite, soft stretchy cheese, and the tomato sauce ugh so good. I only got one slice of a cheese and it was phenomenal. Vibe is...
The Original NY Pizza
$
Closed
(64)
Photos
831 Bass Pro Ln
Cary, NC 27513
The Original New York Pizza in Cary, NC brings a taste of the Big Apple to North Carolina since 1991, offering a wide variety of selections from Calzones to Sicilian pizza, all made with premium Wisconsin cheese and freshly packed Italian tomatoes.
With a commitment to using the finest ingredients, including fresh vegetables and daily-made dough, The Original NY Pizza has been recognized as the best pizza in Western Wake by Maggy Awards and Cary Magazine, solidifying its reputation as the go-to spot for authentic New York-style pizza.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.564 reviews
Steve S.
10/29/2024
Friendly guys behind the counter! Originally from NY and have been living in Seattle area for a decade. Whenever I travel to the east coast I'm always on the lookout for good pizza (can't be...
Isaiah R.
8/3/2025
No hair nets, and no gloves. Bare hands see in cheese bins, staff was not groomed and didn't look like had good hygiene. Left when I saw his bare hands digging in the cheese bins. Rather not get sick
Richard C.
7/6/2025
Yes, i was pleasantly surprised when i went there for pick up. I had an Hawaiian and it was excellent. A great new find very happy I tried them, going back for more tonight!
Janeen C.
2/23/2025
Alex Phelps provided exceptional service! I ordered several pizzas for a basketball watch party. Alex brought them into our building and set them up. There was a miscommunication with the order...
See a problem?
