Mary R.
4/8/2025
Staff was so friendly! Plenty of Alice in Wonderland themed ice creams to choose from. The day we went they had dill pickle and Sriracha flavored ice creams. Hahah not gonna lie...not too...
Mad Hatters Ice Cream Shop
$
Closed
(55)
Photos
1405 Hope Mills Rd
Fayetteville, NC 28304
Mad Hatters Ice Cream Shop is the place to stop for something fresh and tasty! With numerous unique flavors, we have everything your sweet tooth craves. We offer flavors made by Hershey's ice cream plus flavors that are made in-house and our ice cream scoops are as delectable as it gets. Nothing has synthetic flavors, only natural fruits and pulps - and that's why our ice creams have such a unique, homemade flavor to them. We also offer mangonadas, Mexican street corn, cotton candy, hot chocolate, and more. So stop by and grab a seat if you're looking for something you cannot find at any other ice cream shop in Fayetteville, NC. We're right here waiting for you with our constantly rotating menu!
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
5.055 reviews
Janet W.
7/20/2025
A hidden gem for sure!! Been here a few times and just now getting around to leaving a review. The owner is so friendly! Everytime I go theres a new flavor I want to try. The queen of hearts I...
Sarah B.
3/5/2025
What a fun a unique place! The owner was so so friendly when we came in as first timers! The flavors we had were insanely good, some rich, some lighter and I ate every bit of it. I'm definitely...
Lori B.
8/23/2025
Don't let location or outside appearance deter you! We were in town for a weekend college visit and used yelp to find an ice cream shop. Did not disappoint! Highly recommend the pumpkin ice cream!
Linda W.
5/22/2025
Very tasty homemade ice cream and home made and purchased ices and other. Nicely unique flavors. No high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors or additions from the local chemistry lab. The...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.