Taylor W.
8/2/2025
This is really like genuine NYC pizza - perfect crispy crust that has a great bite, good flavor on the sauce and toppings. Price is also very affordable, with slices less than $5. Don't hesitate...
Fentoni’s Pizzeria
Closed
(175)
Photos
1018 N Lake Park Blvd
Carolina Beach, NC 28428
Fentoni's Pizza, a beloved NY-style pizzeria in Carolina Beach, NC, has announced the permanent closure of its current location on the boardwalk due to property sale. However, loyal customers can look forward to the reopening of two new locations in Carolina Beach, promising faster service and a bigger slice shop for summer visitors.
Ranked #3 NY Pizzeria in all of NC by the Washington Post, Fentoni's Pizza is known for its specialty pizzas and daily specials. The upcoming move aims to address parking issues and congestion during peak season, ensuring that patrons can continue to enjoy their favorite pizzas by the beach.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5175 reviews
Tom R.
8/11/2025
Fentoni's is the perfect pit stop when you're in full beach-and-boardwalk mode. This is their slice shop right in the heart of the action, serving up a variety of pizzas by the slice. No waiting...
Bill J.
9/3/2025
We ordered pizza for pick up at Fentoni's location near the Publix Grocery store on Lake Park Boulevard North. They make a really good pizza here... the crust and the sauce are very good, and...
Cecilia M.
7/11/2025
Five stars all the way. Just picked up a large loaded specialty pizza which gives you a choice of five toppings. I added sliced meatballs, pepperoni, spinach, mushrooms, and black olives. This...
Jeff M.
9/10/2025
Saw the great reviews and said to my wife, let's go have a slice of the best pizza in Carolina Beach. Very sorry it was such a let down. We both ordered 2 slices each, and wife also got a house...
See a problem?
