Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

$$
Open
yelp logo

(63)

Photos

16836 Birkdale Commons Pkwy Unit 64
Huntersville, NC 28078

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a charming bakery located in Huntersville, NC, offering a delectable selection of handmade pies made from real, simple ingredients. Owned by sisters Savannah Lape and Gabby Sillyman, the shop aims to bring people together through the shared love of pies, whether it's for a weekday dinner, a holiday celebration, or a thoughtful gift. With a focus on community involvement, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop also partners with local non-profits through their Pie it Forward program, where a unique pie flavor is created to benefit the chosen organization.

With a warm atmosphere, friendly employees, and a commitment to Southern tradition, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop provides a special experience for every guest. Customers are encouraged to sample the various pie flavors and find their favorites, whether it's Savannah's preferred Peanut Butter Cream and Blueberry seasonal or Gabby's favorites of Chocolate Cream and Peach seasonal. As a testament to their dedication to customer satisfaction, the shop also offers a PIE PERKS Club, providing news on seasonal offerings and special deals, including a free 4-inch pie on birthdays with the purchase of any 4 or 9-inch pie.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
4.563 reviews
Food E.
10/10/2025

Staff was very friendly. We tried the mini Spiced Pumpkin pie and it was really good.

Photo of Rose S.
Rose S.
3/29/2025

Everything was too sweet. We had a 4 pie personal sampler. Let's start with the apple. It was a standard apple pie nothing about it stood out except the sugar. It was sweet and we love...

Photo of Stacey A.
Stacey A.
4/1/2025

My Mom loved their custard pie. She was craving a custard pie and after driving around to several bakeries to no avail, we took a trip out to Birkdale Village. I had popped in here before but...

Photo of April H.
April H.
7/19/2025

The worst thing about this pie shop is trying to find a parking spot. It's kind of a bummer to have to park super far away and spend more time getting back and forth than spending two minutes to...

Photo of Sharon D.
Sharon D.
1/26/2025

Nice selection of mini pies this Saturday night after dinner at Fin & Fino. Our faves were the peanut butter pie and the pecan pie.

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNorth CarolinaHuntersvilleButtermilk Sky Pie Shop

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.