Grace D.
7/29/2025
Something about the Outer Banks and pizza just goes so well... and with a slice of pie that struggles to stay on two pizza plates, you will be all set for lunch! The view from either the outdoor...
Benny Tesoro's
Closed
(18)
Photos
7531 S Virginia Dare Trl
Nags Head, NC 27959
Benny Tesoro's is a popular pizza chain with 30 locations, including their newest spot in Nags Head, NC. Known for their mouthwatering pizzas, Benny Tesoro's offers a variety of specialty toppings and classic favorites, all made with high-quality ingredients. Whether you're a cheese lover or prefer a little spice with hot lips cherry peppers, there's a pizza to satisfy every craving at Benny Tesoro's.
With a name that means "treasure" in Italian, Benny Tesoro's pays homage to the pirate history of Nags Head, where treasure-hungry pirates once roamed. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect place to enjoy a delicious pizza feast, whether you're dining in or grabbing a pie to go. So, head over to Benny Tesoro's and indulge in their delectable pizzas that are sure to leave you craving for more.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.018 reviews
Dan P.
8/6/2025
Ordered delivery got a 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage, pepperoni, x-cheese, x sauce. I like my pizza saucy and cheesy, I also selected well done as I like a good crispy crust. It Was delivered hot and...
Charlie T.
9/21/2025
Benny's Tesoro was awesome, it was a few weeks ago and I learned of Benny's Pizza. When I looked them up I saw they were in Nags Head NC and wanted to try. Was not disappointed the pizza was a...
Vinny C.
5/30/2025
The pizza is ENORMOUS! It was very good. Did not skimp on the toppings and they were fast for pickup on a Saturday night. Would buy pizza from here again!
MeeMaw V.
5/15/2025
We ordered a half cheese and half pepperoni/mushroom pizza. It was huge! The box was the size of the oven top. That whole pizza, delivery fee, and delivery tip was around $68. That's an incredible...
See a problem?
