Erin C.
9/29/2025
This is a solid pizza spot right by NYP. IMO the regular slice could've used a little bit more sauce, but the crust was thin, crisp and on point. I also really enjoyed this thicker slice (photo...
York Ave Pizza
$
Closed
(78)
Photos
434 E 72nd St
New York, NY 10021
York Ave Pizza is a vibrant pizzeria located at 434 E 72nd St in New York, NY, offering a diverse menu that features a wide range of Italian-American dishes, including pizzas, pastas, and seafood specials. Known for their quality ingredients and flavorful recipes, the establishment prides itself on providing a comfortable dining experience that appeals to locals and visitors alike.
In addition to traditional slices, York Ave Pizza showcases inventive specials such as their Fried Calamari and Shrimp Parmigiana Platter, making it a go-to spot for both classic and contemporary fare. Whether guests are seeking a quick bite or a hearty meal, the restaurant delivers delicious flavors and generous portions that satisfy any appetite.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.578 reviews
Joyce K.
8/8/2025
Stopped in here for a quick lunch during a workday. There was a short line that moved quite quickly. All the pizzas are on display so you can see what tickles your fancy. I got one slice of crazy...
Amanda G.
8/31/2024
One of my gigs is in the area and I happened upon this pizza shop while trying to find an atm so I could tip my garage guys. After scoring funds next door, I stopped in the shop to grab a seltzer...
Sydney H.
9/19/2024
Ordered delivery through postmates and found the items to be hit or miss: Spicy vodka penne - awesome! Big portion and the sauce was super flavorful and spicy Spinach roll - not great. It was...
Janessa D.
9/20/2025
Paid 7 dollars for a mediocre slice of pizza To start things off I asked for 2 slices and when I came home I realized they only gave me one. Which was upsetting. Not to mention this single slice...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.