Pranda P.
1/15/2023
Let me tell you; after living in NYC, and talking pizza in the Catskills, I've slowly come to the realization that I am a pizza snob. There is pizza rivalry between this spot and Mama's in hunter....
Windham Pizzeria
Closed
(19)
Photos
5339 State Route 23
Windham, NY 12496
Windham Pizzeria is a cozy establishment in Windham, NY that specializes in crafting delicious pizzas using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes.
With a menu featuring a variety of toppings and sizes, Windham Pizzeria offers a casual dining experience for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.519 reviews
Arty W.
7/23/2025
Pretty good local pizza. We had the meat lovers which tasted great. Worth a try in the area.
David R.
2/23/2025
Great pizza all the kids loved it. Very nice family owned small business. Couldn't have asked for a better service.
Gary L.
8/6/2024
Ruben!! Great NYC style pizza on the mountain. Top 5 regular slice. Big fan of the pizzeria. We always stop by for a slice.
Anthony S.
7/6/2022
Visited on 7/2/22. In my humble opinion, this is definitely one of the better pizzerias in upstate N.Y. If it was in N.Y.C., Long Island, Jersey or New Haven CT. it would not warrant such a...
See a problem?
