Kelli D.
12/4/2014
This is my favorite pizza place in the area. The pizza is perfect. It's the gooey kind. If you're into that, this place is for you. When we first moved to the area, my husband tried to order a...
Wilson's Pizza Shop
$
Closed
(30)
Photos
2730 Main St
Newfane, NY 14108
Wilson's Pizza Shop is a family-owned and operated establishment in Newfane, NY, serving the community since 1963. Known for its wide array of offerings, including pizza, deep-fried options, salads, and subs, it has become a local favorite for hearty meals.
The shop also provides delivery services starting at 4 pm, catering to residents from Lake Ontario to the top of Tolgate Hill. With a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality food, Wilson's Pizza Shop continues to uphold its legacy in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.030 reviews
Michael Z.
9/7/2024
Good stuff, was in the mood for some pizza from the Buffalo area and this place didn't disappoint. Detroit deep dish and some wings and there were smiles around the table. Pizza was really good, I...
Cathy Turner ..
4/29/2025
It's so delicious. The owner is happy to tell you the history of the shop and his family. It's comfy. Nowhere to sit so it has to be to go!
Anna D.
7/30/2023
Enjoyed our ranch pizza and wings here. The chicken on the pie was extra crispy just the way we like it
Suzette B.
7/4/2024
Love love love their pizza! Great community business!! Always friendly, not really a sit down place to eat - more of a take out. I was SHOCKED thou to learn they don't have chicken wings any...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.