Kathleen M.
6/26/2025
White Cap catered our lobster bake on Fire Island and it was tremendous. The seafood was so fresh and perfectly cooked and the team was so easy to work with. It was the highlight of our year!!
White Cap Fish Market
$$
Open
(97)
Photos
120 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
White Cap Fish Market, established in 1938, has become a renowned seafood destination in Islip, NY. With a rich history of providing high-quality seafood to restaurants and fish markets, they have expanded their offerings to include prepared foods, take-out dinners, and outdoor dining during the summer.
With a commitment to freshness, White Cap Fish Market ensures the highest quality seafood by controlling every step of the process, from catching to delivering. Whether you visit their retail store or dine in their restaurant, you can enjoy the freshest seafood, ready to eat, and experience the true taste of the ocean.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.597 reviews
Irene S.
8/2/2024
A hidden gem! We absolutely love white cap! We wanted a casual, relaxed, seafood dining on the water and that's exactly what white cap delivers. The food is fresh and delicious. My husband really...
VeeVee P.
8/14/2024
Thought a rustic shack would have amazing seafood but it was okay. Nothing to go back for. Could've been seasoned better. But there are plenty of options in cooking the seafood. Had the broiled...
Jesse Y.
4/13/2023
Cozy, dated but good spot for seafood. Fresh market on site if you plan on taking home some seafood as well. Very spacious outdoor seating.
Linda G.
9/7/2024
Delicious oysters!! $16 for a bakers dozen! Next time crab cakes and clams! Everything looked great! Old school fish market!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.